Paper Comments

You have got to love paper reviews. Here are some excerpts from my reviewers comments on a recent paper:

Premature. Could be a radical new concept, but not enough there to really have any idea what the authors are talking about.

I like the paper. It was well written and well structured, despite the fact that it contains three or four disparate chunks of preliminary work. Your cites are on target.

The paper is completely disorganized. It is almost impossible to make any sense out of it. I really can't figure out what the authors think their contribution is.

The authors demonstrate a comprehensive and clear awareness of the privacy problems of location disclosing applications. The facts presented are mostly justified and followed a clear argumentation path.